Key Points
- Attorney General Ellie Reeves said political considerations would not influence decisions on serious crimes linked to the Troubles.
- She said decisions requiring her consent would be made independently of the Government through a quasi-judicial process.
- Labour Member of Parliament Andy McDonald warned that the Northern Ireland Troubles Bill could weaken safeguards protecting prosecutorial independence.
- Amnesty International United Kingdom called for the consent requirement to be removed before the Bill becomes law.
- The Bill passed the House of Commons on October 20, 2026, and is scheduled for a second reading in the House of Lords on December 2.
Bolded inverted pyramid: Main development first, followed by supporting details and context.
- Key Points
- What did Ellie Reeves say about prosecution decisions?
- Why has Andy McDonald raised concerns?
- What has Amnesty International United Kingdom said?
- What is the current status of the Northern Ireland Troubles Bill?
- What is the background to the dispute?
- How could the development affect victims, veterans and public confidence?
Westminster (East London Times) November 18, 2026 – Attorney General Ellie Reeves has said there will be no political interference in decisions on whether serious crimes linked to the Troubles should be prosecuted. Speaking in the House of Commons, Reeves said decisions requiring her consent would be made independently of the Government through a quasi-judicial process. Her comments came as MPs examined provisions in the Northern Ireland Troubles Bill that would require consent from either the Advocate General for Northern Ireland or the Attorney General for England and Wales before indictable-only Troubles-related offences could proceed.
What did Ellie Reeves say about prosecution decisions?
As reported by the Evening Standard, Ellie Reeves gave an assurance to Labour Member of Parliament Andy McDonald that political considerations would not affect future decisions. Reeves said the decisions would be made “quasi-judicially” and independently of the Government.
Reeves said there were precedents for requiring Attorney General consent in criminal cases. Such consent is already required in England and Wales for some offences, including causing an explosion likely to endanger life or property and most espionage offences under the Official Secrets Act 1989.
Why has Andy McDonald raised concerns?
Andy McDonald, the Member of Parliament for Middlesbrough and Thornaby East, warned that the Bill could roll back safeguards designed to keep prosecution decisions free from political interference.
McDonald referred to the Justice (Northern Ireland) Act 2002, which states that the functions of the Director of Public Prosecutions for Northern Ireland must be exercised independently of any other person. He asked whether requiring Attorney General consent for serious Troubles-related prosecutions would undermine that safeguard and public confidence in Northern Ireland’s justice system.
What has Amnesty International United Kingdom said?
Gráinne Teggart, Amnesty International United Kingdom’s Northern Ireland deputy director, called for the Attorney General consent clause to be removed before the legislation becomes law.
Teggart said an assurance that decisions would be made quasi-judicially did not resolve concerns about prosecutorial independence or public confidence. She said independent prosecution decisions were a vital safeguard arising from reforms that followed the 1998 Good Friday Agreement.
What is the current status of the Northern Ireland Troubles Bill?
The Northern Ireland Troubles Bill cleared the House of Commons on October 20, 2026, and has been sent to the House of Lords for further scrutiny. The Lords has listed the Bill for a second reading debate on December 2.
The legislation would establish a reformed Legacy Commission with enhanced powers and includes amendments concerning prosecutions and protections for veterans. More than 100 Government amendments were added during the Commons stages, including the provision giving the United Kingdom’s Attorney General a role in deciding whether certain serious Troubles-related prosecutions can proceed.
Parliamentary voting records show the Bill passed its third reading by 330 votes to 178. Political parties in Northern Ireland have remained divided over the legislation, with concerns focusing on prosecution safeguards, protections for veterans and the extent of scrutiny given to the amendments.
What is the background to the dispute?
The Government introduced the Northern Ireland Troubles Bill as part of its effort to replace the Northern Ireland Troubles (Legacy and Reconciliation) Act 2023. The legislation follows commitments to reform the legacy process and was developed in the context of co-operation with the Irish Government. Its proposed changes include a reformed body to investigate legacy cases and new rules affecting prosecutions. The requirement for Attorney General consent has become one of the most contested provisions because it places a law officer with ministerial responsibilities in the prosecution process.
How could the development affect victims, veterans and public confidence?
If the Bill remains unchanged, victims and families seeking prosecutions may focus on whether the consent process is sufficiently independent and transparent. Veterans and former security personnel may view the wider legislation as providing additional legal protection, although the consent clause remains controversial. The Government’s position is that quasi-judicial decision-making can prevent political interference, while Amnesty International United Kingdom and critics in Parliament argue that the ministerial role could still weaken confidence in prosecutorial independence. The Lords’ scrutiny and its second reading on December 2 will provide the next formal opportunity for the provision to be examined.
