East London Times (ELT)East London Times (ELT)East London Times (ELT)
  • Local News
    • Redbridge News
    • Hackney News
    • Newham News
    • Havering News
    • Tower Hamlets News
    • Waltham Forest News
    • Barking and Dagenham News
  • Crime News​
    • Havering Crime News
    • Barking and Dagenham Crime News
    • Tower Hamlets Crime News
    • Newham Crime News
    • Redbridge Crime News
    • Hackney Crime News
    • Waltham Forest Crime News
  • Police News
    • Barking and Dagenham Police News
    • Havering Police News
    • Hackney Police News​
    • Newham Police News
    • Redbridge Police News
    • Tower Hamlets Police News
    • Waltham Forest Police News
  • Fire News
    • Barking and Dagenham Fire News
    • Havering Fire News
    • Hackney Fire News​
    • Newham Fire News
    • Redbridge Fire News
    • Tower Hamlets Fire News
    • Waltham Forest Fire News
  • Sports News
    • West Ham United News
    • Tower Hamlets FC News
    • Newham FC News
    • Sporting Bengal United News
    • Barking FC News
    • Hackney Wick FC News
    • Dagenham & Redbridge News
    • Leyton Orient News
    • Clapton FC News
    • Havering Hockey Club News
East London Times (ELT)East London Times (ELT)
  • Local News
  • Crime News​
  • Police News
  • Fire News
  • Sports News
  • Local News
    • Redbridge News
    • Hackney News
    • Newham News
    • Havering News
    • Tower Hamlets News
    • Waltham Forest News
    • Barking and Dagenham News
  • Crime News​
    • Havering Crime News
    • Barking and Dagenham Crime News
    • Tower Hamlets Crime News
    • Newham Crime News
    • Redbridge Crime News
    • Hackney Crime News
    • Waltham Forest Crime News
  • Police News
    • Barking and Dagenham Police News
    • Havering Police News
    • Hackney Police News​
    • Newham Police News
    • Redbridge Police News
    • Tower Hamlets Police News
    • Waltham Forest Police News
  • Fire News
    • Barking and Dagenham Fire News
    • Havering Fire News
    • Hackney Fire News​
    • Newham Fire News
    • Redbridge Fire News
    • Tower Hamlets Fire News
    • Waltham Forest Fire News
  • Sports News
    • West Ham United News
    • Tower Hamlets FC News
    • Newham FC News
    • Sporting Bengal United News
    • Barking FC News
    • Hackney Wick FC News
    • Dagenham & Redbridge News
    • Leyton Orient News
    • Clapton FC News
    • Havering Hockey Club News
  • Cookies Policy
  • Report an Error
  • Sitemap
  • Code of Ethics
  • Help & Resources
East London Times (ELT) © 2026 - All Rights Reserved
East London Times (ELT) > Opinion > The Fundamental Flaw in American Foreign Policy.
Opinion

The Fundamental Flaw in American Foreign Policy.

Dr Michael Reynolds
Last updated: November 21, 2026 11:07 am
Dr Michael Reynolds
43 seconds ago
Senior Law Lecturer (UEL) -
Share
The Fundamental Flaw in American Foreign Policy Explained
Credit: cesran.org

Readers may well be forgiven for being perplexed and confused by the contradictions in American foreign policy regarding the threat to World Peace posed by the illegal Russian war against a democratic, independent sovereign country and the confusing remarks made by Mr Trump and his Under-Secretary of State, Mr Colby in the last few weeks. Readers will be more confused by wondering which side the the United States government is on; whether they support Russia’s illegal aggression in Ukraine and the killing of thousands of innocent civilians, the targeting of hospitals schools and other non-military infrastructure with the resultant liability for war crimes, as well as the unrestrained propaganda directed by Russia against the European Union, the cyberattacks, the hybrid warfare, sabotage, and clandestine operations by proxies disclaiming any relationship with Russia, like the attempted false flag operation at Kaliningrad suggested in the Polish newspapers on 19 November. This is the way Russia has operated in former times well known to allied intelligence agencies. In terms of Britain’s defence it is dependent on NATO and NATO is dependent on all its members meeting their Washington Treaty obligations. The United States is the most powerful military country in the world at present and consequently our alliance with it has been fundamental to our security since 1941.

This week I had the pleasure of attending a meeting at my former International Relations Department with leading speakers about the NATO alliance. There were differing opinions as to what extent we could still rely on America under its current administration. One speaker opined that the element of trust has gone; we can no longer rely on the United States. Another speaker suggested a more positive approach and that in effect Europe had not much alternative other than to rely on the United States. It is self-evident that Mr Trump is not an expert on diplomacy, international relations, history, nor his own constitutional position let alone international law. He still acts like a property tycoon. That is the painful truth.

Ironically despite Trump’s idée fixe with money and self-profit, his country is in enormous debt and it is argued that it is risky to be associated so closely with a country having over $40.62 trillion worth of debt with interest accruing at $3.20 trillion per day. The other concerning issue is the extent of corruption which will have to be addressed by the new Congress if credibility is to be restored for Americans who are not billionaires or multi-national corporations with tax benefits. Another issue for politicians is that it is obvious Mr Trump is not a democrat he leans towards and befriends autocrats. That is not how America behaved before Trump, nor before Lincoln. This is not to say that America was always an ally of Great Britain. It was not our ally during the First World War it was fighting in association with Britain and France. The American Congress vetoed Woodrow Wilson’s promotion of the Treaty of Versailles and rejected membership of the League of Nations. Indeed, during the 1920s and early 30s America considered Europe as the problem. President Roosevelt had difficulty in educating the American public into the danger of fascism and the spread of totalitarianism. The period before the Second World War was marked by regional wars: in 1935 Italy attacked Abyssinia, In 1937 Japan attacked China, in 1939 Germany attacked Poland and then in 1940 proceeded to invade the Low Countries and France so dominating the continent. In 1941 Japan attacked the United States and the Congress passed a War Resolution. This combination of regional wars resulted in total war -the Second World War. What is happening now are two consecutive regional wars one by the United States and it’s illegal war against Iran, and a far more dangerous and devastating war- Russia’s illegal war against Ukraine. It does not take an expert in international relations, diplomacy or a military expert to recognise the danger and the symmetry of these two regional wars. They are connected because China and Russia are supporting their ally Iran, whilst Russia is attacking Ukraine with some Chinese and Iranian, not to mention North Korean and other mercenaries help. The contradiction in US foreign policy is Mr trump’s friend Putin who uses Iranian Shahid drones and facilitates Iranian military in identifying American military bases as targets. So the two autocrats Mr Trump met in Shenzhen are not exactly great friends of the United States, and in foreign policy terms have never been great friends of the United states but for decades have bene seen as potential enemies. It may be obvious to some but China a new superpower is the ace in the pack and Putin and Mr Trump are the two jokers in the pack. In this case China holds the cards not Mr Trump. Trump is seen as the puppet of Putin and after conversations with Putin in Shenzhen it appears that when the Russian false flag operations failed in Kaliningrad to provoke Poland against Ukraine which Polish intelligence prevented then it is likely that Putin asked his friend Trump to put the pressure on NATO and force the Europeans to stop all assistance to Ukraine. It doesn’t take an intelligence analyst to work out the plot.

During the NATO defence ministers meeting this week the Under Secretary of State in the Pentagon advised Ukraine to stop attacking targets in Russia. It appears that there is clearly some difference of opinion amongst members of NATO as to the right of a sovereign state to take any means at its command to defend the life of its citizens as its first constitutional and legal duty mut be the protection of the State.

The German defence minister thought this was stupid and our defence minister Mr Streeting was firmly said that Ukraine had the right to defend itself and he would not dream of telling Ukraine how to defend itself. Mr Streeting made a robust response because Ukraine is a sovereign state and is at liberty to take whatever measures it sees fit. When a country like Ukraine is attacked by one of the superpowers with overwhelming force it must use every means at its disposal for its defence which would include attacking the critical infrastructure of the Russian energy industry. Indeed one could refer to the Dam Busters RAF heroes who destroyed a number of German reservoirs in World War II. I could never imagine President Roosevelt telling MR Churchill not to do so.

In this case Russia continues to devastate Ukrainian infrastructure, attacking hospitals, schools, tower blocks, housing and offices in the major cities and specific attacks against industry.

If Mr Colby the Under Secretary of State at the Pentagon were ever to read this newspaper, which I very much doubt, he might learn something. Not from me, but from a great English diplomat, Sir William Hayter, who was referred to by an eminent American diplomat Dean Acheson who was President Truman’s Secretary of State. Sir William as reported in the Observer newspaper on 2nd October 1960 said as follows:

Negotiation with the Russians does occur, from time to time but it requires no particular skill. The Russians are not to be persuaded by eloquence or convinced by reasoned arguments, They rely on what Stalin used to call the proper basis of international policy, the calculation of forces. So no case, however skilfully deployed, however clearly demonstrated as irrefutable, will move them from doing what they have previously decided to do: the only way of changing their purpose is to demonstrate that they have no advantageous alternative, that what they want to do is not possible. Negotiations with the Russians are therefore very mechanical; and they are probably better conducted on paper than by word of mouth.

Thus, taking Sir Williams point NATO must persuade Russia that it will not give up its support for Ukraine and that if Russia meddles, as it does in Europe and makes any armed attack on any NATO member, it will be met will a full retaliatory response by NATO forces. This would be subject to Article V and NATO members agreement, but in anticipation of any projected attack NATO members should move a Rapid Reaction Force to the area that is vulnerable to deter such an attack, or in the last resort to defend as best they can until reinforcements arrive. That maybe the only message Putin understands because he knows if he fights NATO even without its US ally he will lose as he is losing in Ukraine. He also knows President Xi is not stupid, and China’s patience has a limit. China also may not want to see Europe destroyed by a reckless megalomaniac. Putin was a Lieutenant Colonel in the KGB Counter-Intelligence Service and Director of the Federal Security Service (FSB), between July 1998 and March 1999 so he was trained to know better than loose a war and destroy Russia’s economy.

But what can we do now. The Prime Minister calls for peace as do Trump and Putin. Subject to the pledge to stand by Ukraine as to his great credit the Prime Minister has declared at the NATO meeting this week. Putin maybe bluffing as he has no obvious intention of perpetual peace; he wants Ukraine and his old empire. Trump is obviously taken in and easily led by Putin to the shame of America. Putin has far more experience in this game and will try every trick in Felix Edmundovich Dzerzhinsky playbook. (Dzerzhinsky was the founder of state security for the Russian Bolshevik regime). Then you have Europe wanting to join the talks on any peace agreement. How you get that without a ceasefire is difficult and how you get Germany, France, Britain and the EU with Russia, Ukraine and America in the same room to discuss this another matter. Where they meet is an interesting question presumably not on Boroditsky Hill near the Moskva River and adjacent to Red Square. Mind you one supposes Trump might like the view of the real estate in the area.

But before anyone gets to that point, which may well be a long time coming, the Ukrainian people need humanitarian aid urgently. Kiev was bombed extensively on Wednesday and Thursday including the embassies of Holland and Austria which were damaged. The available utilities for the essentials of life are depleted to the extent that an Atlantic Council member based in Washington said that Kiev needs humanitarian aid. The capital city of Ukraine, Kiev (latest 2026 population estimate of Kiev shows that 2,887,974 people are residing in the city) is constantly being attacked by hundreds if not thousands of drones daily. Its citizens are dying, being injured, its hospitals and schools are being destroyed, as is its infrastructure including energy sources putting the necessities of life at severe risk and strain. So what to do?

In 1948 and 1949 the people of Berlin were starving. The Soviets had blockaded the city, there was no transportation into the western part of the City. The only recourse to the allies namely Britain and France and the United States was to airlift supplies into the Tempelhof airport. In June and July 1948 Britain and America managed to supply the Berliners with 70,000 tonnes of supplies and by May 1949 it reached 250,000 tonnes. Of course, the air capacity of aircraft then was far below todays heavy lift capacity. The United States has that capacity as well as other members of NATO so it should be possible to do more than the minimum that the allies achieved in those years. Of course, some diplomatic effort will be urgently required, but if the Pope and Mrs Trump managed the exchange of prisoners then maybe this humanitarian effort could be achieved. This would be something to focus on as a step towards a ceasefire perhaps but knowing how Russian diplomacy and Trumps misalignment with his friend works it is not promising but simply an idea.

Why International Law is Essential to the Community
Vets under the microscope: Will the CMA vets’ rules fix the high prices?
East London Is Not Your Scapegoat: On Diversity, the Far Right, and Who Gets to Tell Our Story
Standing Up, Speaking Out: Why Representation Matters Now More Than Ever
No Room at the Inn
Dr Michael Reynolds
ByDr Michael Reynolds
Follow:
Dr Michael Reynolds is a Senior Law Lecturer at University of East London teaching professional skills and international commercial arbitration. He is also a Visiting Professor in Dispute Resolution and Arbitration at BPP University Law School. He is a solicitor by profession and a practising Chartered Arbitrator. He is a member of the Atlantic Council (UK) and a former visiting senior research fellow in international relations, international history, and law at the LSE. He was also an academic visitor at Oxford. He has written articles on arbitration, civil justice and recently on international relations and spoken at conferences in Oxford and Cambridge. He has written a number of law books for practitioners as well as two recent books on dispute settlement between states: Instruments of Peacemaking 1918-1941: The Failure of Diplomacy (Hart, Oxford, 2026) and Instruments of Peacemaking 1870-1914 (Hart, Oxford, 2021, and 2023)
Previous Article West Ham eye Manchester United left-back Harry Amass January deal, London 2026 West Ham eye Manchester United left-back Harry Amass January deal, London 2026
East London Times footer logo

All the day’s headlines and highlights from East London Times, direct to you every morning.

Area We Cover

  • Hackney News
  • Havering News
  • Newham News
  • South East London News
  • Redbridge News
  • Tower Hamlets News
  • Waltham Forest News

Explore News

  • Crime News​
  • Fire News
  • Police News
  • Live Traffic & Travel News
  • Sports News

Discover ELT

  • About East London Times (ELT)
  • Become ELT Reporter
  • Contact East London Times (ELT)
  • Street Journalism Training Programme (Online Course)
  • Politicians
  • Journalists
  • Contributors

Useful Links

  • Cookies Policy
  • Report an Error
  • Sitemap
  • Code of Ethics
  • Help & Resources
East London Times (ELT) © 2026 - All Rights Reserved
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?