Key Points
- Reform UK withdrew its planned Senedd debate on freedom of speech hours before it was due to begin.
- The decision came as Reform members continued their boycott of Senedd proceedings.
- The boycott followed a speaking ban imposed on Reform Member of the Senedd Joe Martin.
- Presiding Officer Huw Irranca-Davies said Martin must apologise before being allowed to speak in debates.
- Reform has missed proceedings including First Minister’s Questions and scrutiny of the Welsh Government’s draft budget.
Cardiff (East London Times) November 18, 2026 – Reform UK has withdrawn a planned debate on freedom of speech in the Senedd while its members continue to boycott most proceedings. The motion was cancelled hours before it was scheduled to take place, after the party’s Member of the Senedd Joe Martin was barred from speaking over remarks that the presiding officer described as “unnecessarily provocative and deliberately offensive”. Reform members remained absent from the chamber on Wednesday.
Why did Reform UK withdraw the freedom of speech debate?
As reported by the BBC, Reform UK had tabled a motion stating that the principle of freedom of speech should be upheld and defended. The motion was submitted after Huw Irranca-Davies, the Senedd’s Presiding Officer, prevented Joe Martin from speaking unless he apologised for comments made during business questions.
The BBC reported that Plaid Cymru had proposed an amendment stating that freedom of speech must be exercised within the law. The amendment also said Members of the Senedd should conduct parliamentary business in a way that upheld dignity and respect for all.
The debate was withdrawn on the day it was due to be held. A Reform spokesperson confirmed that the boycott was continuing but did not comment on the cancelled motion, according to the BBC.
What led to the Senedd boycott?
Joe Martin, the Reform Member of the Senedd for Caerdydd Penarth, asked for a statement on what he described as the demographic replacement of white British people in the United Kingdom. Huw Irranca-Davies said the remarks focused on race and ethnicity, were discriminatory and offensive, and detracted from the dignity of the Senedd.
The presiding officer said Martin would not be called to speak until he gave a clear indication that he understood the boundaries of acceptable parliamentary conduct and apologised to the chamber. Martin has said he does not intend to apologise, according to the Daily Post.
Reform UK’s leader Nigel Farage called the ruling “outrageous”, while Helen Jenner, Reform’s leader in Wales, described it as an infringement of freedom of speech and said the party stood behind Martin. Jenner announced that Reform would boycott the Senedd in protest at his treatment.
What has the boycott affected?
BBC reporting said Reform members have been absent from weekly First Minister’s Questions and scrutiny of the Welsh Government’s budget. The South Wales Argus reported that Reform members said they were dissatisfied with progress in discussions with Huw Irranca-Davies about freedom of speech.
Reform members have continued to attend for some votes while remaining absent from much of the chamber’s debate. The County Times reported that James Evans, Iain McIntosh and Andrew Griffin defended continuing the boycott after the speaking ban.
Huw Irranca-Davies appealed to all Members of the Senedd to attend plenary. He said parliamentary participation was central to scrutinising the Welsh Government, debating matters affecting Wales and making decisions on behalf of the public.
What happens to Joe Martin if he returns?
If Joe Martin returns while the ban remains in force, he will be able to ask questions to ministers but will not be called to participate in debates. He will also be unable to ask a question during Senedd business questions, where he made the original remarks, according to the BBC.
Background to the dispute
Reform UK began its boycott after Huw Irranca-Davies barred Joe Martin from speaking in the Senedd. The ruling followed Martin’s reference to the alleged replacement of white British people through immigration, comments that several reports said echoed the far-right “Great Replacement” conspiracy theory. Reform said the restriction infringed freedom of speech and supported Martin’s position. The presiding officer said legitimate immigration policy issues could be raised but parliamentary contributions had to comply with standards of dignity and respect.
How could the dispute affect the freedom of speech debate?
The cancelled motion removes an immediate Senedd vote on how freedom of speech should be balanced with parliamentary conduct rules. Continued absence could reduce Reform UK’s participation in scrutiny of Welsh Government decisions, including budget discussions and ministerial questions. For Reform supporters, the dispute may reinforce claims that the party’s representatives face restrictions; for other Senedd parties, the central issue remains whether members comply with the chamber’s conduct standards. The dispute is likely to keep freedom of speech, parliamentary accountability and the limits of acceptable political language in focus while the boycott continues.
